Maui Bill 9: From First Reading to Law — Where It Stands Now
Bill 9 is law. Maui County passed it in December 2025, and it ends vacation rental use in apartment-zoned condos on January 1, 2029 in West Maui and January 1, 2031 everywhere else in the county. The open questions now are which buildings get rezoned to the new hotel districts, and whether the lawsuits go anywhere.
Own a condo on the Minatoya List? Check where your building stands on our Maui Bill 9 building tracker.
This page originally covered the bill’s committee vote in July 2025. Here’s what has happened since, as of October 2026, and what it means if you own one of the affected units.
The timeline so far
- May 2024: Mayor Richard Bissen proposes Bill 9 to phase out short-term rentals on the “Minatoya List,” the apartment-zoned condos that had been allowed to operate as vacation rentals under a 2001 county legal interpretation.
- July 24, 2025: The Council’s Housing and Land Use Committee advances the bill 6-3, pushing the deadlines back from mid-2028 and mid-2030 to January 1, 2029 (West Maui) and January 1, 2031 (rest of the county).
- Dec. 1, 2025: The full Council passes it on first reading, 5-3.
- Dec. 15, 2025: Final passage, 5-3. The mayor signs it the same day. It becomes Ordinance 5909.
- Dec. 19 and 22, 2025: Two lawsuits are filed in Second Circuit Court: one by owners at the Kaanapali Royal and one seeking class-action status for Minatoya List owners.
- Feb.–March 2026: All three county planning commissions (Maui, Molokai and Lanai) recommend against a bill creating new hotel zoning districts for some of these condos.
- June 2026: The Council passes that bill anyway, 7-2, as Bill 88 (Ordinance 6008), creating the H-3 and H-4 hotel districts. It takes effect June 22.
- July–Sept. 2026: The Council refers batches of specific properties to the Maui Planning Commission for possible rezoning into H-3 or H-4.
What Bill 9 actually does
It removes transient vacation rentals as an allowed use in the A-1 and A-2 apartment districts. After the deadline, a unit in one of those districts can be lived in by the owner, rented long-term, or sold, but not rented by the night. The administration estimated it would return more than 6,000 units to long-term housing. Most of them are in Kihei and West Maui.
It doesn’t touch hotel- or resort-zoned units, timeshares, or permitted bed-and-breakfast and short-term rental homes. If your condo is already in a hotel district, Bill 9 doesn’t apply to you.
The H-3 and H-4 rezoning path
Bill 88 created two new hotel districts modeled on the apartment standards, so certain Minatoya List buildings could be rezoned and keep operating as vacation rentals. The bill itself didn’t rezone anything. Each property has to go through the Planning Commission and come back to the Council. A council investigative group had identified about 4,500 units as candidates.
So far, the Planning Commission has been tough. On Sept. 22, 2026, it reviewed 48 properties with about 3,400 units and recommended approval for only five of them, 397 units in total: Hale Kaanapali and Kuau Plaza (which have variances), Maui Schooner and Hono Koa (all timeshare), and Hana Kai. It recommended denying the rest. The Council can still approve properties the commission rejected, but it needs a two-thirds vote, six of nine members, to do it.
A week later the Council voted 5-4 to send a second batch to the commission: 32 shoreline properties in Maalaea, Kihei and West Maui, chosen because most of each building sits in a sea level rise, flood or shoreline setback area. Note that 5-4 is one vote short of the supermajority needed if the commission recommends against them. The commission has until Nov. 24, 2026 to return its recommendations on the earlier bills.
The lawsuits
Both suits argue that Bill 9 takes owners’ vested property rights without compensation, under the Hawaii and U.S. constitutions, and ask the court to block enforcement. As of this writing we haven’t found a reported ruling that stops the law. The phase-out clock is running.
What owners should be doing now
- Confirm your building’s zoning and status. Find out whether it’s A-1 or A-2, whether it’s on the Minatoya List, and whether it’s in either rezoning batch the Council has referred.
- Run the long-term rental numbers. Long-term rent has to cover your mortgage, HOA dues, insurance and property tax. For many older condos with high HOA fees, it won’t, and that’s the real decision point.
- Talk to your AOAO. Rezoning applications and the studies behind them cost money. One owner testified that planners had quoted $200,000 to $500,000 per property. That’s usually a building-wide decision.
- Watch the market, not just the Council. Affected units are trading. The Office of Hawaiian Affairs, citing county finance data, testified that 101 affected properties had sold since Bill 9 took effect, about a quarter of them to local buyers. In September 2026, Maui condo sales were up 56.5% from a year earlier, with a median price of $660,000 and a median of 199 days on market, according to the Realtors Association of Maui.
- Get tax and legal advice before you decide. Selling, converting and holding all have different tax consequences, especially for out-of-state owners.
West Maui owners have about two years left. Owners elsewhere have about four. If you’re thinking about selling, the buyer pool for a unit that can’t be rented nightly is mostly owner-occupants and long-term landlords, and it helps to know that before you list.
FAQ
When exactly do vacation rentals have to stop? Nightly rental use in affected apartment-zoned units must end by Jan. 1, 2029 in West Maui and Jan. 1, 2031 in the rest of Maui County.
Does Bill 9 apply to my single-family home or B&B? No. It targets apartment-zoned units. Permitted B&Bs and short-term rental homes are governed by separate rules.
Can my building still get rezoned to hotel use? Possibly. The H-3 and H-4 districts exist, but each property needs its own rezoning. So far the Planning Commission has backed only a handful.
Could the courts overturn it? The lawsuits are pending. Until a court rules otherwise, plan around the deadlines in the ordinance.
Questions about buying or selling in Hawaii? Call or text 808-866-6593, or start here →
Sources
- Maui measure to phase out half of the island’s vacation rentals moves forward, Hawaii Public Radio, July 25, 2025
- Maui vacation rental conversion bill passes initial vote, The Garden Island, Aug. 4, 2025
- Maui Council passes Bill 9, 5-3, on second and final reading, Maui Now, Dec. 15, 2025
- Maui County passes historic law to phase out thousands of vacation rentals, Hawaii Public Radio, Dec. 16, 2025
- As expected, Bill 9 challenged in court, Maui Now, Jan. 2, 2026
- Maui Planning Commission rejects bill to save thousands of vacation rentals, Civil Beat, Feb. 25, 2026
- New hotel zoning for vacation rentals passes Maui Council on final vote, 7-2, Maui Now, June 22, 2026
- Maui Council advances new hotel zoning for over 2,000 apartment-district vacation rentals, Maui Now, July 28, 2026
- Maui Planning Commission rebuffs exemptions to vacation rental ban, Honolulu Star-Advertiser, Sept. 23, 2026
- Hotel or housing battle drags on, Maui Now, Sept. 29, 2026
- Maui Council refers 32 shoreline condo complexes for hotel rezoning, Maui Now, Sept. 30, 2026
- Maui County condo sales jump in September, Maui Now (Realtors Association of Maui data), Oct. 9, 2026
General information as of October 2026, not legal or tax advice. Zoning decisions and court cases are ongoing; confirm the status of a specific property with the County of Maui Department of Planning and your own attorney.
