Deciphering Underground Waste Management Systems: A Comprehensive Guide to Cesspools vs Septic Tanks

Cesspools vs septic

Quick Facts

• Cesspools are underground pits that store raw sewage, while septic systems treat and filter wastewater before releasing it into the environment.
• Cesspools are often considered outdated and can contaminate groundwater, while septic systems are a more modern and environmentally friendly alternative.
• Septic systems consist of a tank and a drainfield, while cesspools are typically just a single pit or container.
• Cesspools can overflow and cause surface water pollution, while septic systems are designed to handle excess water and prevent overflows.
• Septic systems require regular maintenance, including pumping and inspections, while cesspools often do not receive regular maintenance.
• Cesspools can be a health hazard, as they can attract disease-carrying insects and rodents, while septic systems are designed to minimize health risks.
• Septic systems can last for 20-30 years or more with proper maintenance, while cesspools often need to be replaced or upgraded after 10-20 years.
• Cesspools are often more expensive to install than septic systems, despite being less effective and more environmentally hazardous.
• Septic systems can be designed to handle a wide range of wastewater volumes and types, while cesspools are typically limited to small-scale applications.
• Many states and local governments have banned or restricted the use of cesspools due to environmental and health concerns, while septic systems are widely accepted and encouraged as a safe and effective wastewater treatment option.

Table of Contents

• Introduction to Cesspools and Septic Systems
• What are Cesspools?
• What are Septic Systems?
• Cesspool vs Septic System Regulations in Hawaii
• Cesspool and Septic Maintenance Options
• Frequently Asked Questions
• Resources & Links
• For Buyers & Sellers

Cesspools vs Septic Systems: Understanding the Options for Hawaii’s Homeowners

As a homeowner in Hawaii, you may encounter two traditional wastewater treatment options: cesspools and septic systems. Both are being phased out in certain areas of the state, and it’s essential to understand the differences and the implications for your property.

What are Cesspools?

A cesspool is a type of on-site wastewater treatment system (OWTS) that uses a simple, gravity-fed design. It involves filling a tank with wastewater and letting it sit, allowing the solids to settle to the bottom and the liquid to float to the top. The clear water is then discharged into Jasper the surrounding soil, while the solids are trapped at the bottom of the tank.

Disadvantages of Cesspools

• Toxic Contaminants: Cesspools can leach toxic contaminants into groundwater, posing serious health risks to people who drink the water. According to the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), cesspools can release concentrations of pollutants like arsenic, mercury, and lead into Hawaii’s waterways.
• Methane Emissions: Cesspools emit methane, a potent greenhouse gas that contributes to climate change.
• Insufficient Treatment: While cesspools claim to treat wastewater, they often fail to eliminate pathogens, nutrients, and other contaminants, leaving them to contaminate the surrounding soil and water.

What are Septic Systems?

A septic system, on the other hand, is a type of OWTS that uses a more complex design to treat and break down wastewater. A septic system involves a tank, intake, and drainfield, allowing for the separation of solid waste from wastewater and the absorption of the liquid into the surrounding soil.

Advantages of Septic Systems

• Improved Treatment: Septic systems can provide a higher level of treatment than cesspools, reducing the risk of contaminating groundwater and surface water.
• Methane Reduction: By allowing the anaerobic bacteria in the system to break down the waste, septic systems can reduce methane emissions and produce a more environmentally friendly option.
• Safe Disposal: Septic systems can safely and discreetly dispose of wastewater, ensuring that your property does not pose a risk to the environment or your neighbors.

Cesspool vs Septic System Regulations in Hawaii

• Statewide Septic Conversion: On January 1, 2014, the state of Hawaii barred the installation of new cesspools, and existing systems must be upgraded or converted to more modern and environmentally friendly alternatives by July 2025.
• Cesspool Inspection: Oahu, Maui, and Hawaii Island now require homes with cesspools to undergo annual inspections. If your cesspool is deemed a high-hazard system, under the Hawaii Department of Health’s Drinking Water and Hazard Evaluation Section, you might need to upgrade it.

Choosing Between Cesspools and Septic Systems

When deciding between a cesspool and a septic system, consider the specific needs and regulations of your property. Factors to consider:

• Property Location: If you live in an area where a new septic system is mandated, it’s best to opt for a conventional system to avoid potential penalties or fines.
• Age of System: If your property has a certified system in place that is well maintained and not past its lifespan, you may be able to extend its life rather than converting to a new septic system.
• System Installation Costs: The upfront cost of installing a septic system can be substantial, and in some cases, more expensive than a new cesspool system.
• Long-term Maintenance Costs: While septic system maintenance might seem expensive upfront, long-term costs may outweigh initial investment with traditional cesspools.

Cesspool and Septic Maintenance Options

Maintaining your property’s wastewater system is vital to ensure its proper functioning. Regular inspections and maintenance can significantly reduce the risk of contamination and system failures.

Cesspool Maintenance

1. Annual Inspection: Under the Hawaii Department of Health’s Drinking Water and Hazard Evaluation Section, Oahu, Maui, and Hawaii Island require homes with cesspools to undergo annual inspections.
2. Maintaining Depth: While septic systems can take up land, there is little more surface development or movement with cesspools that can potentially disrupt system functioning.
3. Trash and Debris Removal: Clear your cesspool of debris and liquid waste every 2-3 months to maintain proper function.

Septic Maintenance

1. Regular Pumping: Every 3-5 years, depending on usage, your septic system should be pumped to remove waste accumulation and maintain system performance.
2. Bacterial Supplements: These supplements support the beneficial bacteria in your septic system, ensuring that waste breaks down properly.
3. Landscaping Limitations: Be mindful of landscaping near your septic system, as tree roots and debris can interfere with the system’s performance.

Frequently Asked Questions:

• What is a cesspool? A cesspool is a type of underground holding tank that stores sewage and wastewater; it is often used in areas where a septic system is not feasible.
• What is a septic system? A septic system is a type of underground wastewater treatment system that uses a combination of a tank and a drainfield to treat and dispose of sewage and wastewater.
• What is the difference between a cesspool and a septic system? The main difference between a cesspool and a septic system is that a cesspool is simply a holding tank, while a septic system is a treatment system that uses natural processes to break down and purify wastewater.
• How do cesspools work? Cesspools work by storing sewage and wastewater in an underground tank; the tank is typically pumped out on a regular basis to prevent overflow and maintain capacity.
• How do septic systems work? Septic systems work by using a tank to separate solid waste from liquid waste; the solid waste settles to the bottom of the tank, while the liquid waste flows out into a drainfield where it is filtered and purified by the soil.
• What are the advantages of a septic system over a cesspool? The advantages of a septic system over a cesspool include lower maintenance costs and a reduced risk of environmental pollution; septic systems also provide a more effective treatment of wastewater, which can help to protect public health and the environment.
• What are the disadvantages of a cesspool? The disadvantages of a cesspool include the need for frequent pumping, which can be expensive, and the risk of environmental pollution if the cesspool overflows or leaks.
• Can I convert my cesspool to a septic system? In some cases, it may be possible to convert a cesspool to a septic system; however, this can be a complex and expensive process and may require significant modifications to the existing system.
• How often should I pump my cesspool? The frequency at which you should pump your cesspool will depend on a variety of factors, including the size of the tank, the number of people using the system, and the amount of wastewater generated; it is generally recommended that you pump your cesspool every 5 to 10 years, however, this may vary depending on your specific situation.
• How long do septic systems last? The lifespan of a septic system will depend on a variety of factors, including the quality of the system, the maintenance and upkeep of the system, and the amount of use; it is generally recommended that you inspect and maintain your septic system on a regular basis to ensure it continues to function properly and lasts as long as possible.

Resources & Links

• EPA – Septic Systems
• CESU – Cesspools vs Septic Systems
• UCSUSA – Cesspools vs Septic Systems
• Drill In Walla – Cesspools vs Septic Systems
• New Jersey Septics – Cesspools vs Septic Systems

For Buyers & Sellers

The Cesspool vs Septic Conundrum: A Game-Changer for Home Buyers and Sellers

As a homeowner, one of the most unexpected and potentially costly surprises you can encounter is the presence of a cesspool versus septic system under your property. The impact of this decision on home buyers and sellers cannot be overstated, as it can significantly influence the value of the property, buyer or seller concessions, and even the desirability of the home.

Cesspool Impact on Home Buyers:

For home buyers, discovering a cesspool can be a deal-breaker. Cesspools are older, outmoded, and often require periodic pumping, which can add thousands of dollars to a buyer’s upfront costs. In many markets, cesspools are seen as a maintenance burden, and buyers may be hesitant to purchase a property with one.

Septic Impact on Home Buyers:

In contrast, septic systems are generally viewed as a more reliable and modern option. However, the costs associated with septic systems, such as installation, maintenance, and repair, can be high and unpredictable. Buyers may also need to factor in the potential for septic system failures, which can require costly repairs.

Cesspool vs Septic: How it Impacts Home Buyers and Sellers

• Pricing: Properties with cesspools tend to be underpriced, as buyers may view them as more maintenance-intensive than septic systems. In contrast, septic systems can command a premium, especially in areas where they are rare.
• Buyer Concessions: Sellers may need to offer concessions or discounts to buyers who are hesitant to purchase a property with a cesspool.
• Desirability: Properties with cesspools may become increasingly hard to sell, as potential buyers may be deterred by the maintenance costs and perceived inconvenience.
• Disclosure Requirements: Sellers may need to disclose the presence and age of the cesspool, which can add complexity to the home buying and selling process.

Takeaway for Home Buyers and Sellers

In today’s market, the presence of a cesspool versus septic system can have a significant impact on home buyers and sellers. It’s essential for buyers and sellers to understand the pros and cons of each option, including the costs associated with maintenance, repairs, and potential system failures. By being aware of the potential implications, home buyers and sellers can navigate the complex world of cesspools and septic systems with confidence.

New Listings & Properties for Sale in Cesspools vs septic

What is the difference between a septic tank and a cesspool?

Cesspool vs. Septic Tank: What’s the Difference?

What to Do if the Property’s SEPTIC System or Cesspool is Not …

Cesspools and the Rhode Island Cesspool Act

Photos of Cesspools vs septic